# Survey Study Overview ## Project Purpose This study examined connections between CAFI community composition and the availability of nearby coral habitat by surveying focal Pocillopora colonies and measuring adjacent coral colonies. --- ## Study Design ### Timing June and July 2019 ### Study Sites (3 locations on Moorea backreef) 1. **MRB**: Mid-North shore 2. **HAU**: Northern end of west shore 3. **MAT**: Southern end of east shore ### Coral Morphotypes (2 categories) - **Tight-branching**: Generally similar to *P. verrucosa* and *P. meandrina* - **Wide-branching**: Generally similar to *P. eydouxi* ### Sample Design - **Per site**: n = 21 focal colonies - **Morphotype distribution**: 10-11 wide-branching, 10-11 tight-branching - **Total colonies surveyed**: 63 (across 3 sites) ### Focal Colony Selection Criteria 1. Clearly fit one of the two morphotypes 2. ~20-30cm in diameter 3. Positioned in location with: - Relatively even distribution of nearby Pocillopora habitat - Homogeneous terrain (not on top of a bommie) 4. Varied in degree of isolation from other Pocillopora colonies ### Environmental Context - **Water depth**: 2-3m - **Distance from reef crest**: 30-150m --- ## Field Methods ### Survey Protocol (conducted on SCUBA) #### 1. Focal Colony Measurements **Manual measurements with flexible tape:** - **Length (L)**: Longest horizontal axis - **Width (W)**: Longest perpendicular measurement to length - **Height (H)**: Perpendicular to L and W - **Circumference**: Colony circumference - **Height above substrate**: Vertical distance from colony base to nearest reef pavement (for colonies above seafloor) **Volume calculation:** - Calculated as hemi-ellipsoid - Previously validated method for relating Pocillopora spp. volume to CAFI biodiversity #### 2. Neighborhood Survey (2m radius) From center of focal colony, measured all Pocillopora colonies within 2m radius: - Length, width, height (same metrics as focal colony) - Circumference - Height above substrate - Hemi-ellipsoid volume - **Horizontal distance** from focal coral base - **Orientation** relative to reef crest #### 3. Colony Collection - Enclosed colonies in polypropylene sack to retain CAFI - Removed coral at base using mallet and chisel - Transported in collection sacks via boat to Gump Research Station in seawater buckets --- ## Laboratory Methods (Gump Research Station) ### Tissue Sampling 1. **Colony re-measurement**: Verified field measurements 2. **Nubbin collection**: Removed ~5cm sections from ends of two branches - Immediately frozen at -20°C for coral tissue property measurements 3. **Genetic sampling**: Collected 2 verrucae using sterilized cutters - Stored in 1mL RNA later at room temperature for genetic identification ### CAFI Extraction Protocol 1. **Anesthetic immersion**: Immersed corals in eugenol solution (100mg/L seawater) for 5 minutes 2. **Flushing**: Rapidly dunked colonies 5-10 times in eugenol solution 3. **Manual removal**: Used forceps to remove any remaining CAFI 4. **Isolation**: Poured eugenol solution through 1mm mesh and isolated visible CAFI ### CAFI Identification **Timeline:** - **Same-day identification**: When possible - **Preserved specimens**: 90% ethanol for later identification (typically within 72 hours) **Methods:** - **Common, well-catalogued CAFI**: On-site identifications - **Rare, small, or cryptic CAFI**: Photographed under dissecting microscope for future identification **Reference materials:** - Moorea Biocode - UC Berkeley Cal Photos collection **Taxonomic updates:** - Nomenclature maintained and updated through January 2025 - Based on most recent accepted entry in World Registry of Marine Species (WoRMS) ### CAFI Measurements **On-site specimens** (calipers): - **Crabs**: Carapace width - **Worms**: Total length - **Snails**: Shell length - **Fish**: Total length - **Echinoderms**: Disc width - **Shrimps, hermit crabs, squat lobsters**: Carapace length **Microscope specimens** (ImageJ with scale bar): - Unknown CAFI requiring photography ### Biomass Conversion - **Fish**: Length-to-biomass conversion using relationships from FishBase - **Invertebrates**: Length-weight relationships calculated from subset of individuals - Desiccated in drying oven at 60°C for 24 hours - Weighed after desiccation --- ## Size Survey (Supplementary Study) ### Purpose Measure the relationship between CAFI community characteristics and coral colony size. ### Timing July and August 2019 ### Study Sites Same three backreef sections as neighborhood survey (MRB, HAU, MAT) ### Sample Design - **Per site**: 12-16 corals - **Size range**: ~5-50cm diameter - **Morphotypes**: Evenly split between wide- and tight-branching - **Total**: 40-48 colonies across 3 sites ### Habitat Context Control Selected focal corals from areas with: - Consistent, moderate amounts of nearby Pocillopora habitat - **Note**: Nearby habitat not explicitly surveyed (unlike neighborhood survey) - Goal: Minimize variation in CAFI composition related to nearby colony abundance ### Methods Identical CAFI collection, measurement, and identification methods as neighborhood survey. --- ## Key Methodological Notes ### Hemi-Ellipsoid Volume Previously validated proxy for Pocillopora habitat volume and CAFI biodiversity. ### Measurement Consistency - Same metrics used for focal and neighboring colonies - Enables direct comparison of colony sizes within neighborhoods ### CAFI Preservation Two-track approach balances: - Speed of same-day identification (fresh specimens) - Accuracy of preserved specimens for challenging taxa ### Taxonomic Rigor - Reference to established Moorea collections - Updated nomenclature ensures current taxonomic standards - WoRMS as final authority on accepted names ### Habitat Context Differences - **Neighborhood survey**: Explicitly measured nearby habitat - **Size survey**: Controlled for habitat by site selection, no explicit measurement