# Tip vs. Stump Comparison Study (December 2019) ## Associated Data File **File name**: 1.tip_stump_comparison_dec_2019 **Google Sheets link**: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/u/0/d/1ugGL1CkC8gZUPFtlLosZD26NC3qv4h05YvxjB5DyQGs/edit --- ## Study Overview ### Purpose Compare physiological characteristics between two parts of coral branches (tip vs. base/stump) to determine if tissue properties vary along the branch axis. ### Sample Origin - **Original collection**: Summer 2019 (part of Neighborhood Survey) - **Processing date**: December 2019 - **Storage**: Frozen at -80°C from Summer 2019 to December 2019 - **Source study**: Survey of Pocillopora neighborhoods and associated CAFI communities from three Moorea sites **Additional context**: See "Neighborhood Survey" sections in the Survey Study Overview documentation: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1OZDKEE5pS03mpbribsQAWCLkoE1veHoh/edit?usp=drive_link&ouid=109953423342820447184&rtpof=true&sd=true ### Sample Processing 1. Thawed frozen branches 2. Fragmented into two parts: **tip** and **stump** (base) 3. Conducted physiological measurements on each fragment --- ## Study Motivation ### Primary Hypothesis **Tip tissue is thinner than base tissue** due to new skeletal growth, which could lead to: - Lower physiological measurements from tip fragments - Bias if only tips are used for tissue analysis ### Alternative Hypothesis **Base tissue has lower physiological activity** due to: - Decreased sunlight exposure at branch base - Potentially reduced energy exchange with symbiotic *Symbiodinium* --- ## Measurements Conducted ### 1. Protein Concentrations **Purpose**: Test if physiology varies between branch parts **Protocol**: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1-KBlubSQE8Exh9UyYGwSATy4jvVO7dJF/edit?usp=sharing&ouid=103283395250523134119&rtpof=true&sd=true **Data notes**: - Some samples excluded from summary data due to contamination (noted in raw data) - **Units**: Best estimate based on other protein measurements from survey and field experiment corals (raw data lacks unit labels) ### 2. Ash-Free Dry Weight (AFDW) **Purpose**: Test if tissue thickness varies between tip and stump **Protocol**: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1LHV0ZH3yF1CKqAn4XWlZbSwpSg994wDb/view?usp=sharing **Interpretation**: - AFDW serves as proxy for tissue thickness - Higher AFDW indicates more organic tissue mass ### 3. Surface Area (Wax-Dipping Method) **Purpose**: Scale physiological measurements appropriately by surface area **Protocol**: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1h_czwMSYU3YWM7rL7c6u-MaJjKIWdfzB3uq1QfrR-3o/edit?usp=sharing **Use**: Enables normalization of protein and AFDW measurements to tissue surface area --- ## Data Limitations and Notes ### Symbiodinium Counts (Not Available) - **Original intent**: Compare *Symbiodinium* densities between tip and stump - **Status**: Never measured adequately - **Existing file**: One test file exists with no indication of whether from tip or stump https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1iS8XJuvPuhDVSEmP_hbVFBosGdgMU2IcGY4iFtUwhrA/edit?usp=sharing ### Protein Concentration Units - **Uncertainty**: Raw data has no recorded units - **Resolution**: Units inferred from other protein measurements in survey and field experiment datasets - **Confidence**: Best estimate, not definitively confirmed --- ## Key Methodological Considerations ### Long-Term Storage - 5-6 month storage at -80°C may affect tissue properties - Consider potential freezer storage artifacts when interpreting results ### Branch Fragment Selection - Tip: Terminal ~5cm of branch - Stump: Basal portion near attachment point - Clear spatial separation ensures distinct tissue zones ### Surface Area Normalization - Critical for comparing physiological metrics between fragments of different sizes - Wax-dipping method provides 3D surface area estimates --- ## Last Modified January 2025 by AP